The Seoul Central District Court has ruled in favor of Young Poong and MBK Partners in their lawsuit seeking to cancel resolutions adopted at Korea Zinc’s shareholders’ meeting. The court found that Korea Zinc could not use mutual-share rules to restrict an existing shareholder’s voting rights for the purpose of defending management control.

The ruling concerns the meeting at which Young Poong’s voting rights were excluded and resolutions were passed on amendments to the articles of association and the appointment of directors and audit committee members. Young Poong and MBK said the decision confirms that voting rights cannot be removed arbitrarily. Korea Zinc said the judgment conflicts with Supreme Court precedents and an earlier Supreme Court decision on an injunction involving the same voting dispute.

The dispute began after Korea Zinc Chairman Choi Yun-beom’s side arranged an in-kind dividend of Young Poong shares held by Korea Zinc’s subsidiary Sun Metal Corporation to its Australian affiliate Sun Metal Holdings. Korea Zinc then relied on the resulting mutual-share relationship to restrict Young Poong’s voting rights at the meeting.

A dispute over mutual-share rules

Young Poong and MBK filed for an injunction and later brought the main action seeking cancellation of the meeting resolutions. Korea Zinc said the application of the mutual-share rules should be reconsidered by a higher court, while Young Poong and MBK argued that the rules and precedents must be applied consistently to the specific facts. Korea Zinc plans to appeal, so the first-instance ruling does not settle the continuing management-control dispute.