The Seoul High Court has rejected a 168.2 billion won tax refund claim brought by nine Lone Star-related entities against the South Korean government and Seoul Metropolitan Government. The court also rejected a related local tax claim against Gangnam District. The ruling came in a retrial ordered after the Supreme Court sent the case back for further consideration.
The dispute concerns taxes imposed on income from Lone Star’s investments in Korea Exchange Bank, Kukdong Engineering & Construction and Starlease. Through holding companies established in Bermuda and Belgium, Lone Star acquired about 416.75 million Korea Exchange Bank shares between 2003 and 2005. It later received a dividend of 416.75 billion won in 2007 and sold 87.7 million shares for 1.19 trillion won.
Lone Star argued that the Korea-Belgium tax treaty applied and that taxes had already been withheld when the dividend and sale proceeds were paid. Tax authorities instead treated Lone Star, rather than the overseas holding companies, as the beneficial owner of the income and assessed corporate taxes accordingly.
- Claim value
- 168.2 billion won
- Earlier government refund
- About 22.8 billion won
- Court
- Seoul High Court
In 2017, the Supreme Court held that the existing taxation was unlawful because Lone Star did not have a fixed place of business in Korea. The government refunded about 22.8 billion won, taking the position that only taxes paid directly by Lone Star were refundable. Lone Star sought repayment of the remaining amounts withheld at source and had won in lower courts before the retrial ruling.
The Seoul High Court’s decision leaves the additional refund claim rejected at this stage. The ruling distinguishes the earlier finding on the legality of taxation from the separate question of which payments qualify for repayment, keeping the scope of the government’s refund obligation at the center of the dispute.
