A dispute over allegations that the former Moon Jae-in administration illegally monitored private real-estate experts intensified during a National Assembly audit of the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport on October 7. The ruling People Power Party said a document listing real-estate experts amounted to a blacklist targeting critics of the government’s housing policies. The Democratic Party rejected the claim as a political attack based on unverified material.
People Power Party lawmaker Kim Eun-hye’s office released what it described as a 38-page document believed to have been prepared in 2019. The document, titled “Current Status of Real-Estate Experts,” reportedly included statements critical of government policy, such as claims that regulations cannot defeat the market and that the price-ceiling system would fail. It also contained information about individuals’ property holdings, including locations and purchase timing. Names were redacted, and the document did not identify its authoring institution or writer.
The party alleged that the Ministry of Land had instructed the Korea Real Estate Board to prepare the material. It characterized the document as evidence of illegal surveillance of civilians and accused the former government of using state power against people who criticized its real-estate policies. Those allegations have not been established by the document itself, and the sources cited in the reports say that its origin and preparation process remain unclear.
The witnesses who appeared before the audit committee did not confirm the allegations. Officials who had worked at the Korea Real Estate Board and the ministry either said they did not remember the document or denied having access to the relevant information. Lee Dong-hwan, a Korea Real Estate Board district branch head and former housing statistics department chief, said his department had no authority to access private real-estate assets and had never investigated them.
The unresolved question of the document’s origin
The Democratic Party argued that the material should not be treated as conclusive evidence before its provenance is verified. Lawmaker Bok Gi-wang said presenting an unidentified document as established fact risked turning the audit into a venue for political conflict. The dispute became heated, with lawmakers from both parties exchanging accusations and raised voices during the session.
The central unanswered question is who created the document, for what purpose, and whether any government agency directed or used it. Until those points are clarified, the People Power Party’s surveillance allegation and the Democratic Party’s claim of a groundless political offensive remain competing interpretations. Further examination of the document’s source, chain of custody and relationship to public agencies is expected to determine whether the controversy develops into a verified misconduct finding or remains a partisan dispute.
