The National Assembly’s Legislation and Judiciary Committee became the site of a sharp dispute over judicial independence and politically sensitive trials during its comprehensive audit on October 26. Opposition lawmakers criticized Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae over the Seoul High Court’s acquittal of Seoul Mayor Oh Se-hoon in a political-funds case and over sentence reductions involving defendants in the insurrection case. They argued that recent rulings and court procedures had damaged public confidence in the judiciary.

Democratic Party lawmaker Lee Seong-yoon called for Cho’s impeachment and questioned the reasoning behind the ruling in Oh’s case, the composition of the panel and the allocation of former President Yoon Suk Yeol’s case. Other lawmakers also raised concerns about whether the Supreme Court’s leadership and judicial administration exercised excessive influence over politically significant proceedings.

The National Court Administration rejected the suggestion that the chief justice or court officials direct lower-court judgments. Noh Kyung-pil said individual panels reach decisions independently after reviewing evidence and facts. He also explained that Yoon’s case and the case involving former Defense Minister Kim Yong-hyun were assigned randomly, while later related cases were assigned as connected matters.

The ruling People Power Party responded by pointing to President Lee Jae-myung’s suspended remand appeal in a public-office election law case before the same Seoul High Court. Its lawmakers argued that calls to defend judicial independence should also include a demand to resume that proceeding. The dispute therefore extended beyond individual rulings to the concentration of personnel and administrative authority in the chief justice’s office. The Democratic Party leadership said it would consider legislative changes and a parliamentary investigation into the allegations surrounding the Oh case, but no institutional change was confirmed at the audit.