South Korea’s Supreme Court has sent former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo’s case back to the Seoul High Court after finding that part of his conviction for performing an important role in insurrection could not stand. The full bench partially overturned the appellate judgment that had sentenced Han to 15 years in prison. His detention was extended by two months, so the remand does not result in his immediate release.

Court
Supreme Court full bench
Decision
Partial reversal and remand
Remand court
Seoul High Court
Custody status
Detention extended by two months

The ruling separates Han’s conduct before the martial law proclamation from his actions after it. The court found insufficient evidence that his request to convene a Cabinet meeting before the proclamation was intended to help achieve the disruption of the constitutional order. It nevertheless left intact the lower court’s finding that Han participated in the insurrection after martial law had been declared.

The court separated conduct before and after the proclamation

Lower courts had treated the Cabinet meeting request as part of an effort to create the appearance that martial law had undergone formal Cabinet deliberation. The Supreme Court took a narrower view. It said the request alone did not establish that Han supported martial law or shared the purpose required for liability as an important participant in insurrection.

The judgment added a more demanding inquiry into individual criminal responsibility. Awareness that a plan may be unlawful is not, by itself, enough to prove participation in an insurrection. Prosecutors must also establish that the defendant intended to contribute to realizing the plan’s purpose of disrupting the constitutional order. On the evidence presented, the majority concluded that this intent had not been proved for the request to convene the Cabinet.

Three justices disagreed with that part of the ruling, according to reports on the judgment. They viewed Han’s involvement in creating the appearance of Cabinet consideration as conduct that gave legitimacy to a self-coup. The disagreement shows that the remand concerns how Han’s personal intent should be inferred from the pre-proclamation meeting request, rather than whether the martial law declaration itself was lawful.

The remaining conviction returns for resentencing review

The court maintained the finding of criminal participation for conduct after the proclamation, including discussions about how to implement measures involving the interruption of electricity and water supplies to media organizations. It also held that the December 3 martial law declaration was unconstitutional and unlawful, and that using military and police forces to obstruct the National Assembly’s exercise of authority amounted to insurrection.

Han had initially received a 23-year prison sentence. The appellate court reduced that term to 15 years after acquitting him on some allegations, but the Supreme Court has now partially overturned the appellate judgment as well. The Seoul High Court must reassess the case within the limits set by the Supreme Court, including the exclusion of the Cabinet meeting request from the insurrection conviction unless the remaining proceedings support a legally sufficient finding.

The decision is therefore not a full acquittal. The finding concerning Han’s post-proclamation participation remains, while one significant pre-proclamation act has been removed from the existing basis for conviction. The remand court will determine how that narrower scope affects the final judgment and sentence, and Han will remain detained while that process continues.