South Korea’s governing Democratic Party formally adopted the impeachment of Supreme Court Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae as its party position on Nov. 20, accelerating a confrontation with the judiciary one day after the Supreme Court sent part of former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo’s insurrection case back for review. The decision authorizes the party to pursue impeachment, but an impeachment motion has not yet been introduced or voted on by the National Assembly.

The party established an impeachment task force and held its first meeting immediately after the decision. Democratic Party leader Kim Min-seok condemned the Supreme Court ruling as a historically misguided decision that had exceeded the limits of public patience. Supreme Council member Seo Mi-hwa argued that the court was creating an unconstitutional precedent under which a failed coup could be forgiven.

This completely misguided, historically regressive decision has exceeded the limits of public and historical patience.

The task force identified several possible grounds for impeachment. They include the Supreme Court’s remand decision in President Lee Jae-myung’s election law case, Cho’s refusal to renominate a Supreme Court justice and allegations involving improper use of operating expenses. Task force leader Yang Bu-nam said the party would also consider whether to include the Han ruling and intended to proceed quickly, without allowing the initiative to extend into next year.

The Han decision provided the immediate political trigger. On Nov. 19, the Supreme Court’s full bench overturned part of an appellate ruling that had sentenced the former prime minister to 15 years in prison and returned the case to the Seoul High Court with instructions reflecting a partial acquittal. The Democratic Party characterized that result as an unacceptable interpretation of conduct connected to the martial law declaration.

Opposition grows inside and outside the governing party

Resistance has emerged both outside and within the governing party. Some Democratic Party lawmakers warned that impeaching the chief justice could cause the judiciary to be viewed as a victim of political pressure. Lawmakers also reportedly proposed a vote during the party meeting because they considered the process of adopting the position one-sided, but that proposal was not accepted.

The opposition People Power Party described the initiative as retaliation for an unfavorable judicial outcome. Floor leader Jeong Jeom-sik said its underlying motive was revenge for the Supreme Court ruling in Lee’s election law case. The political dispute now centers on how the Democratic Party converts its official position into a specific impeachment motion, which allegations it includes and whether internal objections affect the timetable promised by the task force.