South Korea’s Supreme Court has ruled for the first time that the December 3 martial law declaration was not only unconstitutional and illegal but also an act of insurrection intended to disrupt the constitutional order. The full bench reached that conclusion unanimously, giving lower courts an authoritative standard for the criminal cases arising from the declaration.
The court found that no wartime, armed-conflict or comparable national emergency existed when former President Yoon Suk Yeol declared martial law. It concluded that mobilizing troops and police in an attempt to take control of the National Assembly and media organizations violated the constitutional order. The judgment came 716 days after the declaration.
The ruling did not, however, treat every official connected to martial law as automatically criminally liable for insurrection. In the case of former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo, the Supreme Court rejected one of three findings of participation that lower courts had accepted and returned that portion of the case under a not-guilty rationale.
That distinction separates the legal character of the martial law declaration from the conduct of each defendant. Prosecutors must still establish how an individual contributed to the alleged insurrection and whether that person acted with the required intent. Official position or involvement alone is insufficient under the court’s reasoning.
Individual criminal liability remains a separate inquiry
The decision is expected to shape Yoon’s appeal on the charge of leading an insurrection, with a hearing set for January. It establishes that the martial law measure itself was an insurrectionary act, but it does not eliminate the need for the appellate court to assess Yoon’s own actions and intent from the evidence in his case.
Political parties emphasized different parts of the judgment. The Democratic Party raised the possibility of impeaching Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae while criticizing the portion favorable to Han. The People Power Party welcomed the limit placed on individual liability. The January appeal will show how the Supreme Court’s distinction between an unlawful insurrection and personal participation is applied to the former president.
