The appeals court has upheld a 12-year prison sentence for a 29-year-old mother whose 19-month-old daughter died after prolonged neglect. The Seoul High Court’s Incheon Circuit dismissed both the prosecution’s appeal and the defendant’s appeal. The court also retained orders requiring 200 hours of child-abuse treatment and barring employment at child-related institutions for 10 years.
- Appeals ruling
- Both appeals were dismissed and the 12-year sentence remained in place
- Additional orders
- The defendant must complete treatment and face a 10-year employment restriction
- Child’s condition
- The girl weighed 4.7 kilograms when she died from malnutrition and dehydration
Investigators found that the child died from malnutrition and dehydration after being left without sufficient milk or solid food. Her weight was 4.7 kilograms at death, less than half the average 10.4 kilograms reported for girls of the same age. The child had become too weak to hold her own bottle, while the mother left her alone for as many as 67 hours without food on one occasion. During the five days before the death, the child was reportedly alone at home for 92 of 120 hours while her mother visited an amusement park and a sauna.
The first trial and the appeals court found that the mother’s neglect caused the death, but ruled that the evidence did not prove she recognized and accepted the possibility of death. The courts therefore applied the offense of causing death through child abuse rather than child-abuse murder. The case also included allegations that she physically abused her older daughter twice. The appeals court said no new circumstance justified changing the original sentence.
