A Seoul administrative court has ruled in favor of a science high school teacher who sought official-duty medical benefits after developing a rare sarcoma following years of using 3D printers for student instruction. The court overturned the personnel agency’s rejection of his application, finding a sufficient causal relationship between his work and the disease.

The teacher began working at a science high school in Gyeonggi Province in 2013 and used 3D printers in classes from 2015. Four printers were operated repeatedly over a long period in an enclosed computer room without adequate ventilation, exposing him to substances released during printing. He was diagnosed with sarcoma in April 2020 and subsequently applied for treatment coverage as an occupational injury.

The personnel agency denied the application because it found insufficient scientific evidence connecting 3D printer use with sarcoma. The court said, however, that a work-related causal relationship does not have to be established with complete medical or scientific certainty. Based on a hospital assessment and relevant studies, the judges found it reasonable to conclude that continued exposure to carcinogenic substances during printing contributed to the teacher’s illness.

Scientific uncertainty did not defeat causation

The court noted that research had clearly identified cellular toxicity in substances emitted by 3D printers and had not completely excluded their carcinogenic potential. It also considered the rarity of sarcoma among men aged 35 to 44, whose annual incidence is about 2.2 to 2.3 cases per 100,000 people. The judges said the likelihood that two teachers exposed to similar hazardous substances would develop the same rare disease at roughly the same time was very low.

The ruling emphasizes that the absence of definitive research does not by itself defeat an occupational injury claim when workplace conditions, medical findings and epidemiological circumstances collectively support causation. The available evidence does not state whether the judgment has become final, leaving any appeal or later procedural outcome to be confirmed.