A Seoul appellate court has kept the cancellation of the Saemangeum International Airport basic plan in place, finding that the government did not adequately examine the site’s unusually high bird-strike risk. The Administrative Division 4-2 of the Seoul High Court dismissed the appeals, leaving the first-instance judgment against the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport intact.
The lawsuit was filed by 1,296 citizens, while the appellate court recognized standing for three plaintiffs who live within the area covered by airport noise measures. The court concluded that the ministry had placed excessive weight on development benefits over human safety and environmental protection. It said the danger should have been assessed at the site-selection stage, rather than addressed mainly through management measures after choosing the location.
Site selection came before a full safety review
Risk modeling for the proposed airport indicated a substantially greater threat of bird strikes than at other domestic airports. The plaintiffs cited research suggesting that the risk could be as much as 650 times that at Muan International Airport. The ministry and North Jeolla Province disputed that comparison, arguing that it assumed no preventive facilities and that deterrence systems and alternative habitats could control the danger.
The court was not persuaded that those measures sufficiently reflected the site’s position on the East Asian-Australasian Flyway. It also found that relying on operating experience at the nearby Gunsan Airport did not replace a detailed assessment of the proposed site. A single bird strike could cause severe loss of life and property, the court said, making aviation safety a priority even while acknowledging the region’s economic development needs.
Environmental effects were also central to the ruling. Airport construction could reduce feeding, resting and breeding areas for birds, damage biodiversity and affect habitat conditions around the nearby Seocheon tidal flats. The first-instance court had additionally cited the project’s benefit-cost ratio of 0.479 when canceling the plan.
The airport was selected as a national balanced-development project in 2019 and exempted from a preliminary feasibility study. Its basic plan was announced in 2022. If the judgment becomes final, the ministry may have to prepare a new basic plan or reconsider the site and scale of the project, while provincial investment, transport and logistics strategies built around the airport could face further delays and revision.
