A dispute over which agency should investigate a suspected artificial-intelligence hacking incident at a financial institution has exposed a gap in South Korea’s cybercrime jurisdiction system. The Seoul Serious Crimes Investigation Office notified police that the police should continue the case after reviewing its progress. The decision came two days after the National Police Agency referred the matter, arguing that the affected system could qualify as an electronic financial infrastructure facility and therefore fall within the office’s remit for serious cybercrime.

Police began a pre-indictment investigation on October 1. Investigators have secured and analyzed access records and requested cooperation from the US Federal Bureau of Investigation. The serious-crimes office cited that progress in deciding that a transfer was not necessary. Police said the investigation would continue despite the notification and rejected the idea that the dispute amounted to either responsibility shifting or a suspension of the inquiry.

The case illustrates how jurisdiction can become unclear when a suspected cybercrime involves several possible offenses and agencies apply different legal standards. Under the Serious Crimes Investigation Office law, police must promptly notify the office when they identify a serious crime, and they must transfer the case if the office requests it. In this instance, however, the office concluded that the police were already conducting the more appropriate investigation.

Police investigation began
October 1, before the jurisdiction notification
Jurisdiction coordination rules
Scheduled to take effect on February 5 next year
Serious-crimes office decision
Police should continue the current investigation

A formal body intended to resolve jurisdictional disagreements is not scheduled to take effect until February 5 next year. Until then, agencies may have to settle similar disputes through provisional decisions while technical evidence continues to develop. The report also identified early infrastructure concerns at the new office, including a vacant cyber information investigation leadership post, delays in transferring forensic equipment and incomplete functions in parts of the criminal justice information system. Those conditions could make rapid coordination harder in a case requiring log analysis and international cooperation.