A dispute has emerged over how South Korea selected the quantum-computing site for a national quantum cluster backed by 100 billion won in state funding. Chungcheong Today reported that Seoul was selected after competing with three consortiums representing Seoul; Daejeon, Sejong and Chungnam; and Gangwon, Incheon and Chungbuk. The reporting focused on whether the final site inspection could meaningfully affect the result.

According to documents obtained through an information disclosure request, the Ministry of Science and ICT completed an expert evaluation and sent the development plan and designation proposal to 20 related agencies on July 10, seeking responses by July 30. The on-site inspection of the locations and facilities proposed by local governments took place later, on August 3 and 4. Scores for facilities, basic infrastructure, and research, testing and demonstration infrastructure had already been assigned during the document and presentation evaluations in June.

The inspection itself received no separate score or ranking, and no disclosed standard appears to have specified how its findings could change the candidate selection. The ministry said the public call was evaluated primarily on the development plan, while the inspection was intended to confirm the availability and usability of the spaces and facilities described in that plan. It also said the final designation was confirmed through a resolution of the Quantum Strategy Committee after the inspection.

What the disclosed timeline shows

The sequence has prompted criticism because the ministry had described expert review, interagency consultation and the site inspection together as part of the candidate-selection process. Chungcheong Today reported that the ministry declined to release the inspection report and requests for supplementary material, citing information about detailed implementation plans and future calls. The available reporting establishes a transparency dispute over the inspection's role, but does not verify that a particular evaluator had a conflict of interest or that the result was changed improperly.